How likely is a "State Election" in 2027?

MEXICO - Report 16 Nov 2026 by Guillermo Valdés and Francisco González

A State Election in 2027, that is, one in which public institutions (governments, electoral referees, prosecutors, public budget) cease to be neutral and act in favor of the party in power, would compromise governability for the rest of the six-year term. To measure how far the 2027 electoral process is from a fair contest, we built a State Election Index: 44 indicators in eight dimensions, scored from 0 (institutions play for one side) to 100 (a free, competitive, legal and fair process), drawing on the work of Levitsky and Way, Schedler and Norris. The referee (INE and OPLEs) and the governments weigh 20% each. At Cutoff 2 the index stands at 52.3, in the “uneven playing field” band and 5.1 points below the recalculated Cutoff 1 (57.4).

The weakest dimensions are legitimacy and trust, the electoral authority (39) and governments (42). Governments, legitimacy and the legal framework fell 13 points each between Cutoff 1 (mid-October) and Cutoff 2 (November 12), driven by the INE corruption scandal, the cut in the 2027 budget, which leaves the INE without adequate capacity to perform its functions, and the foreign-interference annulment rule, which could be applied discretionarily, especially given that various US authorities have accused Morena politicians of links to organized crime. Electoral justice (75) holds. Seven of the eight indicators that changed fell. With polarization rising and Morena unwilling to seek consensus on the INE presidency, positions are likely to harden, and the trend toward a State Election is likely to deepen. Criminal interference will become more visible as candidate selection advances, and a new Cutoff is due in mid-December.

Our diagnosis is that the 2027 process will be held on an uneven field, and that the risk lies in how it is conducted and contested. Before election day, we expect disputed candidate selection, pressure and criminal interference in pre-campaigns, alongside an INE and Electoral Tribunal stretched by complaints and challenges on a reduced budget. On election day and in the days after, the main risks are local violence and coercion, vote buying, contested results and litigation, with the annulment rule as a possible tool for discretionary outcomes. For the final three years of the Sheinbaum administration, the implication is that a midterm result obtained on this field would weigh on the legitimacy of the new Congress and the governors. A comfortable majority would come with weaker checks and balances, while a disputed outcome would mean prolonged conflict with the opposition. Either path would strain governability.

Now read on...

Register to sample a report

Register
Must have at least 8 characters